Camera opinion's Options

[gt_driFFter]

I can't decide if I want the Canon S3 IS, or to pony up the extra $$ for the Canon Digital Rebel XT (350D). Anybody have experience with either of these? I mainly want to shoot cars, and pictures of the skyline/sunset. Please post up your opinions on either of these camera's!

*EDIT*
No longer looking at the S3, just trying to decide between the Canon Rebel XT, and XTi. Please see the 5th post in this thread!

This post has been edited by gt_driFFter: Jul 4, 2007 - 1:13 AM

[Mynzeyes]

I just purchased the Canon S3-IS. I'm completely happy with my purchase, and it is an amazing camera for the price. As for the 350D, I do not think it is worth well over double the price. As with any DSLR, you are going to need all the different attachments in order to make it a well-rounded camera. With the S3-IS, it is pretty much ready right out of the box. The only main thing I would recommend is a lens hood and filter, available for around 30 dollars. There was a review somewhere on the net comparing the S3-IS to a 5000 dollar DSLR, but I cannot find it right now. However, I do remember that there was definitely not a 4600 dollar difference in pictures. For a 6mp Super-Zoom P&S camera with all of the mods and abilities as the Canon, you cannot go wrong. Especially if you are really just a novice, and just now getting started in learning about the in-depth properties of serious photography, it is a great camera.

You can compare the S3-IS side-by-side to the 350D here:
http://www.imaging-resource.com/IMCOMP/COMPS01.HTM
My opinion based on those comparisons is, spend the less money, and go with the S3-IS. If you want more zoom, or wide angle, you can always get attachments. But based on those pictures, the 350D is not worth well over twice the price (to me).

Also, another good forum is here:
http://www.stevesforums.com/forums/

And, here is a PowerShot S3-IS only forum:
http://www.powershots3.com/

I'll keep looking for that comparison with the DSLR, but for now, check out a couple of those links. Based on those 2, I say the S3-IS is the better buy, but use those to help you make your own decision.

-John-